|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
6.1000000
|
3.4600000
|
1.2000000
|
1.0000000
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
All
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
Large Reef (>1m)
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
39.2308000
|
5.9337573
|
45.1049000
|
5.3403533
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.11
|
|
|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
537.7000000
|
356.0000000
|
380.9000000
|
170.6955770
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
Large Reef (>1m)
|
1000
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
43.7000000
|
21.4800000
|
6.9000000
|
8.9378297
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Concrete
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
unsure
|
All
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
63.2000000
|
27.2000000
|
42.5000000
|
43.1335136
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
Large Reef (>1m)
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
1.0000000
|
1.2000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Understory kelp
|
All
|
|
|
unsure
|
Large Reef (>1m)
|
100
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
43.6800000
|
33.4300000
|
114.8960000
|
62.4180000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Hexaminus
|
Austrominius
|
Thoracica
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 2 - September deploy
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
43.6800000
|
33.4300000
|
20.4900000
|
12.8000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Hexaminus
|
Austrominius
|
Thoracica
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 2 - September deploy
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
43.6800000
|
33.4300000
|
15.3600000
|
8.3500000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Hexaminus
|
Austrominius
|
Thoracica
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 2 - September deploy
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1.9672100
|
0.5000000
|
6.3934400
|
0.5000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Significant - no repeated measures, there were enough replicates to remove separate replicates each month and then remainder stayed behind.
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1.9672100
|
0.5000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.5000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1.9672100
|
0.5000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.5000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
19.1803000
|
0.5000000
|
26.0656000
|
0.5000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
19.1803000
|
0.5000000
|
18.1967000
|
0.5000000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
19.1803000
|
0.5000000
|
13.2787000
|
13.2512496
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
23.6066000
|
7.8304063
|
79.6721000
|
12.0467130
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
23.6066000
|
7.8304063
|
33.9344000
|
8.4327359
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
23.6066000
|
7.8304063
|
11.3115000
|
2.9508250
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
38.3607000
|
18.6723378
|
73.2787000
|
4.8186362
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
38.3607000
|
18.6723378
|
41.3115000
|
24.0933036
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
38.3607000
|
18.6723378
|
39.3443000
|
2.9508500
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
43.0070000
|
2.9667372
|
42.7972000
|
3.5601412
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.11
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
33.1469000
|
10.0873025
|
37.0000000
|
4.1538281
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.11
|
|
|
Walker 2002
|
2002
|
26.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
23.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
25x1.2m diameter, 25x1.5m diameter
|
1.13112 x 25 and 1.7673 x 30
|
Y
|
Reef
|
|
RockvsTire
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.77
|
-80.14
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Text
|
|
|
Walker 2002
|
2002
|
26.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
22.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
25x1.2m diameter, 25x1.5m diameter
|
1.13112 x 25 and 1.7673 x 29
|
Y
|
Reef
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.77
|
-80.14
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Text
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
22.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
17.0000000
|
NA
|
22.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Ambrose 1994
|
1994
|
16.8000000
|
6.6000000
|
21.5000000
|
0.7071068
|
4
|
2
|
2
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
Large Reef (>1m)
|
check Ambrose 1987 paper
|
Y
|
Reef
|
N/A
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Subtidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
33.36
|
-117.56
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
Open
|
Not measured in this study (can check associated studies)
|
Table
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
17.0000000
|
NA
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
18.7393000
|
1.1290000
|
19.7483000
|
0.6448000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
WoodvsPerspex
|
Turpentine Tree
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
18.3250000
|
3.1280000
|
19.7483000
|
0.6448000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
17.3420200
|
5.5786585
|
17.9015000
|
4.8023534
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Concrete
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1923.3200000
|
570.8000000
|
1826.0000000
|
246.7400000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
5.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 3 - May deploy
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1923.3200000
|
570.8000000
|
250.5880000
|
115.9240000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
5.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 3 - May deploy
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
1923.3200000
|
570.8000000
|
215.1920000
|
84.9380000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
5.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 3 - May deploy
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig 2
|
|
|
Anderson 1996
|
1996
|
15.0299000
|
4.0336000
|
101.8960000
|
13.1080000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea commercialis
|
Saccostrea glomerata
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
ConcretevsSStoneSite1NoBio
|
Rock (sandstone)
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid tidal level
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-32.719802
|
152.101625
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Oyster trestles
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig3, Table 2 (s)
|
Concrete is actual concrete (rather than the E3 - epoxy concrete lookalike) and sandstone is actual sandstone
|
|
Anderson 1996
|
1996
|
19.4118000
|
11.0924000
|
119.2440000
|
22.1840000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Saccostrea commercialis
|
Saccostrea glomerata
|
Saccostrea
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
ConcretevsSStoneSite2NoBio
|
Rock (sandstone)
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid tidal level
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-32.719802
|
152.101625
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Oyster trestles
|
Sheltered
|
S
|
Fig3, Table 2 (s)
|
Concrete is actual concrete (rather than the E3 - epoxy concrete lookalike) and sandstone is actual sandstone
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
7.9913300
|
7.5665000
|
4.4508700
|
4.8352700
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
7.9913300
|
6.6560600
|
2.1242800
|
2.5000000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
9.1040500
|
9.3876500
|
3.8439300
|
3.0144800
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
18.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
12.4422000
|
7.5665000
|
20.1301000
|
15.7601000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
48.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
13.3526000
|
7.5665000
|
19.8266000
|
16.6700000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
60.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
16.2861000
|
15.7601000
|
10.0145000
|
13.0286000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
30.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
18.4104000
|
2.1044000
|
22.7601000
|
23.9537000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
42.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
19.9277000
|
13.0295000
|
16.8931000
|
15.7601000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
66.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
21.5462000
|
14.8502000
|
29.0318000
|
28.5059000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
72.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Blakeway et al 2013
|
2013
|
22.2543000
|
23.9537000
|
14.5665000
|
22.1330000
|
54
|
54
|
54
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
0.6 ha reef
|
0.0625
|
Y
|
Reef
|
horizontal and vertical
|
rockvsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
6.5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
36.000000
|
-23.3837
|
116.4431
|
Dampier, Western Australia
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 8
|
Quadrats only, no settlement plates. 3 replicates of each substrate at each subsite.. 6 quadrats per subsite substrate - (3 horiz and 3 vert): 3 sites x 3 substrate reps x 6 quadrats = 54 quadrat replicates per substrate type. SD estimates looked wrong - I think the previous replicate estimate could have been wrong and not updated.. have changed, using n of 54 (SE*sqrt(54))
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
2.6270200
|
3.4295300
|
3.2364400
|
3.9872300
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsconcrete_DDD
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
4.7996300
|
5.8223800
|
3.2364400
|
3.9872300
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsconcrete_DDD
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
6.9547600
|
8.2753300
|
3.2364400
|
3.9872300
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsconcrete_DDD
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
2.6270200
|
3.4295300
|
6.2901000
|
7.7492900
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsterracotta
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
2.6270200
|
3.4295300
|
6.2901000
|
7.7492900
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsterracotta
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
6.9547600
|
8.2753300
|
6.2901000
|
7.7492900
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsterracotta
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.258113
|
55.264398
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_DDD
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0850218
|
0.1477280
|
0.0439155
|
0.0900944
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsconcrete_PRT
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.2059480
|
0.3030700
|
0.0439155
|
0.0900944
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsconcrete_PRT
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.2479110
|
0.3509960
|
0.0439155
|
0.0900944
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsconcrete_PRT
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0850218
|
0.1477280
|
0.0876906
|
0.1805970
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsterracotta
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.2479110
|
0.3509960
|
0.0876906
|
0.1805970
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsterracotta
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.2059480
|
0.3030700
|
0.0876906
|
0.1805970
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsterracotta
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.018135
|
55.031183
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Breakwater_PRT
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0389587
|
0.0783963
|
0.2020080
|
0.3054210
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsconcrete_NR1
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.3496420
|
0.5125440
|
0.2020080
|
0.3054210
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsconcrete_NR1
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.4065000
|
0.5494560
|
0.2020080
|
0.3054210
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsconcrete_NR1
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0389587
|
0.0783963
|
0.2303650
|
0.3274170
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsterracotta
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.3496420
|
0.5125440
|
0.2303650
|
0.3274170
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsterracotta
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.4065000
|
0.5494560
|
0.2303650
|
0.3274170
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsterracotta
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_1
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0451193
|
0.0904432
|
0.0805453
|
0.1367430
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsconcrete_NR2
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0468966
|
0.0936433
|
0.0805453
|
0.1367430
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsconcrete_NR2
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.1684650
|
0.2394390
|
0.0805453
|
0.1367430
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsconcrete_NR2
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0451193
|
0.0904432
|
0.0932822
|
0.1565420
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
sandstonevsterracotta
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.0468966
|
0.0936433
|
0.0932822
|
0.1565420
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
granitevsterracotta
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
0.1684650
|
0.2394390
|
0.0932822
|
0.1565420
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
ALL
|
Anthozoa
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed
|
gabbrovsterracotta
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.936369
|
54.911106
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural reefs_2
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 2
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
65.4000000
|
38.0131556
|
79.2000000
|
8.8543774
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
80.2000000
|
25.4911749
|
79.2000000
|
8.8543774
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
gabbrovsconcrete
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
85.3000000
|
29.0688837
|
79.2000000
|
8.8543774
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
65.4000000
|
38.0131556
|
74.5000000
|
28.1744565
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
sandstonevsterracotta
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
85.3000000
|
29.0688837
|
74.5000000
|
28.1744565
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
granitevsterracotta
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Burt et al. 2009
|
2009
|
80.2000000
|
25.4911749
|
74.5000000
|
28.1744565
|
20
|
20
|
20
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Mixed (parallel to substrate)
|
gabbrovsterracotta
|
Gabbro
|
Rock_gabbro
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
4m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
24.974592
|
54.965726
|
Dubai
|
Persian Gulf
|
Natural and breakwater mixed
|
Exposed
|
Not Significant
|
Text
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
16.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
16.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
16.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvsmetal
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
16.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
24.3070000
|
64.0547801
|
29.8507000
|
31.0159355
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
24.3070000
|
64.0547801
|
20.6823000
|
36.4101487
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
24.9467000
|
37.0843463
|
29.8507000
|
31.0159355
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
1.1304
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
4.5 - 6m on sandy bottom 100m offshore
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
24.9467000
|
37.0843463
|
20.6823000
|
36.4101487
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
50.5330000
|
8.0913198
|
59.4883000
|
15.5078097
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
50.5330000
|
8.0913198
|
50.9595000
|
47.1982590
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
56.0768000
|
16.1820072
|
64.8188000
|
11.4623078
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
56.0768000
|
16.1820072
|
60.1279000
|
8.0913198
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
56.0768000
|
41.1298482
|
59.4883000
|
15.5078097
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
56.0768000
|
41.1298482
|
50.9595000
|
47.1982590
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
70.3625000
|
16.8565211
|
72.7079000
|
9.4397150
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
70.3625000
|
16.8565211
|
71.4286000
|
6.7426084
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
72.4947000
|
13.4852169
|
64.8188000
|
11.4623078
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
72.4947000
|
13.4852169
|
60.1279000
|
8.0913198
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
72.7079000
|
7.4168060
|
72.7079000
|
9.4397150
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
72.7079000
|
7.4168060
|
71.4286000
|
6.7426084
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
76.9723000
|
8.0910036
|
85.9275000
|
9.4397150
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
76.9723000
|
8.0910036
|
75.2665000
|
6.0684108
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
82.0896000
|
28.9930265
|
89.3390000
|
5.3942132
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
82.0896000
|
28.9930265
|
87.4200000
|
6.7426084
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
84.8614000
|
12.8110193
|
85.9275000
|
9.4397150
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
84.8614000
|
12.8110193
|
75.2665000
|
6.0684108
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
86.3539000
|
10.7884265
|
89.3390000
|
5.3942132
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Metal
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervsmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
86.3539000
|
10.7884265
|
87.4200000
|
6.7426084
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
2.25
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
bouldervstyre
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
7.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2 b
|
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
17.3420200
|
5.5786585
|
15.8011700
|
4.8213020
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
14.9678200
|
5.9108659
|
14.9738100
|
5.2275372
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
15.2871700
|
4.4276415
|
13.6531300
|
4.2709948
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
18.7393000
|
1.1290000
|
13.3967000
|
1.1286000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
WoodvsSteel
|
Turpentine Tree
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
18.3250000
|
3.1280000
|
13.3967000
|
1.1286000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
RockvsSteel
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
13.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
14.9678200
|
5.9108659
|
12.9842300
|
6.1140008
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Concrete
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
21.0000000
|
NA
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
14.0000000
|
NA
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
60
|
60
|
60
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvsmetal
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
19.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Table1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
10.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
11.5000000
|
0.5600000
|
11.5200000
|
0.6100000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
320
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
FigIII.D.11
|
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
15.2871700
|
4.4276415
|
11.3103400
|
4.7454035
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Concrete
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
10.0530000
|
0.8370000
|
11.1900000
|
0.4700000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
320
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
FigIII.D.11
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
16.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
9.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
53.4500000
|
NA
|
39.8000000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
1.839884
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
8 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
53.4500000
|
NA
|
67.6000000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
1.839884
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
8 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
53.4500000
|
NA
|
55.4100000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
1.839884
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
8 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.5100000
|
NA
|
67.1900000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.299855
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
10 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.5100000
|
NA
|
44.2600000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.299855
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
10 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.5100000
|
NA
|
50.6100000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.299855
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
10 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.1100000
|
NA
|
67.2800000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.759826
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
12 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.1100000
|
NA
|
49.2300000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.759826
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
12 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
54.1100000
|
NA
|
47.2700000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
2.759826
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
12 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
42.4800000
|
NA
|
72.2400000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.219797
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
14 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
42.4800000
|
NA
|
36.1400000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.219797
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
14 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
42.4800000
|
NA
|
40.5300000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.219797
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
14 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
37.1960000
|
NA
|
72.3200000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.679768
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
16 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
37.1960000
|
NA
|
32.3200000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.679768
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
16 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
37.1960000
|
NA
|
41.1000000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
3.679768
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
16 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
39.2300000
|
NA
|
72.8800000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.139739
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
18 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
39.2300000
|
NA
|
36.7900000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.139739
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
18 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
39.2300000
|
NA
|
47.0300000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.139739
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
18 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
55.9000000
|
NA
|
71.9900000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.599710
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
20 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
55.9000000
|
NA
|
49.5600000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.599710
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
20 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
55.9000000
|
NA
|
55.4100000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
4.599710
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
20 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.7000000
|
NA
|
79.3900000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.059681
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
22 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.7000000
|
NA
|
56.9500000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.059681
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
22 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.7000000
|
NA
|
63.7800000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.059681
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
22 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.3000000
|
NA
|
83.3700000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.519652
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
24 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.3000000
|
NA
|
63.8600000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsHDPE
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
HDPE
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.519652
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
24 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Chase2015
|
2015
|
66.3000000
|
NA
|
74.1100000
|
NA
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0064
|
Y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
granitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
NA
|
N
|
5.519652
|
43°04’14.5"N
|
70°42’46.5"W
|
University of New Hampshire Coastal Marine Laboratory in New Castle, NH
|
|
24 wks
|
|
USA
|
Figure 2.4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
14.7527000
|
12.0402869
|
32.4475000
|
48.5141780
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_winter deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
14.7527000
|
12.0402869
|
9.1886800
|
12.3929148
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_winter deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
14.7527000
|
12.0402869
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_winter deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
20.9926000
|
20.3077458
|
53.4491000
|
40.9482184
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_summer deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
20.9926000
|
20.3077458
|
15.9305000
|
10.9860256
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_summer deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
20.9926000
|
20.3077458
|
6.6997500
|
11.6519714
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Montipora species (coral)
|
Montipora
|
Anthozoa
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii_summer deploy
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 2., table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
33.3333000
|
53.7720459
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 8
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
6.6666700
|
13.3099353
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 14
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 2
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
86.1882000
|
9.6376766
|
79.9142000
|
11.4696871
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
86.1882000
|
9.6376766
|
31.9384000
|
20.5769684
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
86.1882000
|
9.6376766
|
13.7677000
|
20.4318923
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
26.1905000
|
20.7634564
|
38.0952000
|
29.2817574
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 13
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
26.1905000
|
20.7634564
|
28.0952000
|
28.2169418
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 7
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
26.1905000
|
20.7634564
|
11.9048000
|
12.2452225
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
72.2557000
|
19.6619693
|
76.2201000
|
7.8557540
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
72.2557000
|
19.6619693
|
49.8171000
|
35.1328765
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
72.2557000
|
19.6619693
|
19.9012000
|
35.2752245
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
6.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 12
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 6
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
3
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 0
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
48.0655000
|
40.2492236
|
60.1763000
|
12.7225560
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
48.0655000
|
40.2492236
|
26.0361000
|
26.1201809
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
48.0655000
|
40.2492236
|
4.3316600
|
7.7104409
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
8.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
24.5238000
|
9.5831165
|
13.8095000
|
14.9070602
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 11
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
24.5238000
|
9.5831165
|
9.7619000
|
12.7775185
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 1
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
24.5238000
|
9.5831165
|
5.7142900
|
7.9859603
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 5
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
56.3760000
|
7.8450000
|
61.8700000
|
20.3372619
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
56.3760000
|
7.8450000
|
38.5473000
|
16.7222108
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
56.3760000
|
7.8450000
|
34.1283000
|
34.1684603
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres_winter
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
12.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
29.7619000
|
12.2451555
|
24.0476000
|
27.1521262
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
14.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 10
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
29.7619000
|
12.2451555
|
6.1904800
|
4.2591952
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
14.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 2
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
29.7619000
|
12.2451555
|
4.0476200
|
3.7267874
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
14.000000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 4
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
22.8571000
|
29.2817574
|
20.2381000
|
18.6338253
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
Coralvsconcrete
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
18.500000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 9
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
22.8571000
|
29.2817574
|
16.6667000
|
23.4255401
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvsmetal
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
18.500000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Not Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 3
|
|
|
Fitzharding & Bailey-Brock 1989
|
1989
|
22.8571000
|
29.2817574
|
10.2381000
|
12.7775409
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Tunicates
|
|
|
|
15 x 15cm plates
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
coralvstyres
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
18.500000
|
21.275659
|
-157.749979
|
Hawaii
|
Kahala, Onahu, Hawaii
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Significant
|
Fig. 3., Table 3
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
617.0000000
|
409.2004399
|
1513.0000000
|
572.4334022
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
shellvsconcrete
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
929.0000000
|
377.8954882
|
1513.0000000
|
572.4334022
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1207.0000000
|
782.6237921
|
1513.0000000
|
572.4334022
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
617.0000000
|
409.2004399
|
1131.0000000
|
766.9713163
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
shellvsporcelain
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
929.0000000
|
377.8954882
|
1131.0000000
|
766.9713163
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
limestonevsporcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1207.0000000
|
782.6237921
|
1131.0000000
|
766.9713163
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
riverrockvsporcelain
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1022.0000000
|
465.1021393
|
1242.0000000
|
505.3513629
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
shellvsconcrete
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1447.0000000
|
429.3250517
|
1242.0000000
|
505.3513629
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1556.0000000
|
362.2430124
|
1242.0000000
|
505.3513629
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
riverrockvsporcelain
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1022.0000000
|
465.1021393
|
891.0000000
|
93.9148550
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
shellvsconcrete
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1447.0000000
|
429.3250517
|
891.0000000
|
93.9148550
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
George et al. JCCO 2015
|
2015
|
1556.0000000
|
362.2430124
|
891.0000000
|
93.9148550
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
9x9cm
|
1
|
y
|
trays of equal sized substrate bits
|
Hotizontal trays
|
riverrockvsporcelain
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
28.21
|
-96.94
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
sheltered
|
|
Not measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0360000
|
0.0111803
|
0.0200000
|
0.0089443
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Aug
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0090000
|
0.0134164
|
0.0050000
|
0.0044721
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
July
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0070000
|
0.0044721
|
0.0110000
|
0.0111803
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
July
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0070000
|
0.0044721
|
0.0030000
|
0.0044721
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
July
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0090000
|
0.0134164
|
0.0170000
|
0.0201246
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Jun
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0090000
|
0.0134164
|
0.0120000
|
0.0089443
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Jun
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0330000
|
0.0223607
|
0.0270000
|
0.0022361
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
June
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0010000
|
0.0022361
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Sept
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0140000
|
0.0178885
|
0.0150000
|
0.0089443
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Sept
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0140000
|
0.0178885
|
0.0020000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Sept
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0290000
|
0.0111803
|
0.0330000
|
0.0178885
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Aug
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0290000
|
0.0111803
|
0.0180000
|
0.0134164
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
M. charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
Mytella charruana
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
PlexivsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Aug
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0010000
|
0.0022361
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Sept
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0090000
|
0.0134164
|
0.0100000
|
0.0044721
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
July
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0330000
|
0.0223607
|
0.0470000
|
0.0380132
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
June
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Gilg 2010
|
2010
|
0.0360000
|
0.0111803
|
0.0470000
|
0.0178885
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
P. viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
Perna viridis
|
|
9x9cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Downward
|
TerracottavsWood
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
30.4
|
-81.46
|
USA
|
Sister’s Creek, Jacksonville, Florida
|
Marina
|
Aug
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 1
|
Attached facing downwards below floating dock. 1 month deployment and then recovered in each case (new one put out each time)
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
9.0000000
|
NA
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
4.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
12.2602800
|
5.8610174
|
10.2471500
|
3.0030297
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Concrete
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
37.3333000
|
8.9442719
|
48.0000000
|
20.8698932
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
37.3333000
|
20.8701169
|
48.0000000
|
20.8698932
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
11.3333000
|
2.9815730
|
16.6667000
|
7.4534854
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
38.0000000
|
4.4721360
|
16.6667000
|
7.4534854
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
17.3333000
|
7.4537090
|
40.6667000
|
17.8885438
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
14.0000000
|
8.9442719
|
40.6667000
|
17.8885438
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
7.3333300
|
2.9814389
|
16.6666700
|
7.4535525
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
6.0000000
|
4.4721360
|
16.6666700
|
7.4535525
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
11.3333000
|
4.4721360
|
29.3333000
|
16.3979809
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
15.3333000
|
11.9258450
|
29.3333000
|
16.3979809
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
8.0000000
|
2.9814165
|
4.0000000
|
2.9814165
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
10.0000000
|
5.9629225
|
4.0000000
|
2.9814165
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Invertebrates
|
Spirorbids
|
Spirorbides
|
Serpulidae
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
3.3333300
|
2.9814389
|
2.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
0.6666670
|
1.4907038
|
2.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
8.0000000
|
2.9814165
|
12.6667000
|
8.9442719
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
4.6666700
|
2.9814165
|
12.6667000
|
8.9442719
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
3.3333300
|
5.9628554
|
2.6666700
|
1.4906971
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
0.6666670
|
1.4907038
|
2.6666700
|
1.4906971
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
6.6666700
|
2.9814165
|
11.3333000
|
14.9071944
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
12.0000000
|
8.9442719
|
11.3333000
|
14.9071944
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
17.3333000
|
10.4350584
|
10.6667000
|
13.4164079
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
4.0000000
|
4.4721360
|
10.6667000
|
13.4164079
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
31.3333000
|
31.3049517
|
41.3333000
|
26.8328157
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
22.0000000
|
23.8514663
|
41.3333000
|
26.8328157
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Invertebrates
|
Balanus variegatus
|
Amphibalanus variegatus
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
86.3928980
|
43.9764180
|
84.9003500
|
46.5971523
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
98.8021070
|
42.7171629
|
123.1111880
|
70.4613015
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
136.4891100
|
92.6521251
|
144.1076530
|
91.9813651
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
90.0657700
|
46.4941813
|
97.0928224
|
56.7754354
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
85.4122827
|
64.8678944
|
97.0948570
|
62.5936159
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
129.1427480
|
66.3990145
|
125.6408370
|
81.3896455
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
73.9952380
|
31.4917707
|
84.9003500
|
46.5971523
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
75.8151180
|
40.9244446
|
123.1111880
|
70.4613015
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
94.8526800
|
77.2021029
|
144.1076530
|
91.9813651
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
horizontal
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
87.6469200
|
65.4302403
|
97.0928224
|
56.7754354
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site1
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
71.6764167
|
56.9621576
|
97.0948570
|
62.5936159
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site2
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Glasby2000
|
2000
|
111.2486600
|
79.0126471
|
125.6408370
|
81.3896455
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1.5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.000000
|
33.48
|
151.14
|
Middle Harbour, Sydney Harbour, Site3
|
Tasman Sea, Australia
|
reef
|
sheltered
|
1.5m below MLWS - “ALL” is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
Figure 2
|
ALL is the sum of all species in fig 2, and the habitat formers from this fig are also reported.
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
8.3790000
|
NA
|
13.4260000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
11.3650000
|
NA
|
13.4260000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
15.6790000
|
NA
|
13.4260000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
Can get SD from a boxplot by taking the range/4.
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
0.3110000
|
NA
|
0.5620000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
C. viriginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
0.4570000
|
NA
|
0.5620000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
C. viriginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
0.5370000
|
NA
|
0.5620000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
C. viriginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
22.8640000
|
NA
|
30.9440000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
All Oysters
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Apendix S1.1.1
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
25.1610000
|
NA
|
30.9440000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
All Oysters
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Apendix S1.1.1
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
29.0440000
|
NA
|
30.9440000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
All Oysters
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Apendix S1.1.1
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
556.5900000
|
NA
|
895.0800000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Oyster Spat
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Appendix S1.1.2
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
754.9100000
|
NA
|
895.0800000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Oyster Spat
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
S
|
Appendix S1.1.2
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
840.6700000
|
NA
|
895.0800000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Oyster Spat
|
Crassostrea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
S
|
Appendix S1.1.2
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
2.9070000
|
NA
|
2.5150000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
1
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure 5
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
4.5500000
|
NA
|
2.5150000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
1
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
S
|
Figure 5
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
5.4640000
|
NA
|
2.5150000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Biogenic
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
1
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
S
|
Figure 5
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
4.3760000
|
NA
|
5.4680000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Serpulids
|
Serpulidae
|
Serpulidae
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsRiverRock
|
River Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
table 1 - could add mobile invertebrates.. And fish. Mean density /m2
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
6.3350000
|
NA
|
5.4680000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Serpulids
|
Serpulidae
|
Serpulidae
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsLimestone
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Graham et al 2016
|
2016
|
6.8210000
|
NA
|
5.4680000
|
NA
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Tube_forming
|
Tube-forming
|
Serpulids
|
Serpulidae
|
Serpulidae
|
|
12.7x15.2cm vs 7.6x10.2cm
|
0.15
|
Y
|
mounds
|
Horizontal
|
ConcretevsShell
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Sub
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
15.000000
|
28.06
|
-97
|
USA
|
Mission-Aransas Estuary, Gulf of Mexico
|
|
sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
5.5292500
|
3.5095311
|
8.1927200
|
5.9662319
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
7.8882100
|
2.8076070
|
8.1927200
|
5.9662319
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
12.6259000
|
8.4228209
|
15.4411000
|
7.7209191
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
15.8786000
|
8.4228209
|
8.1927200
|
5.9662319
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
16.1826000
|
10.8795887
|
24.3347000
|
15.4418382
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
21.5048000
|
9.4757853
|
24.3347000
|
15.4418382
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
22.4992000
|
9.8266243
|
15.4411000
|
7.7209191
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
23.9217000
|
10.8795887
|
15.4411000
|
7.7209191
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
98.9989000
|
59.6607533
|
24.3347000
|
15.4418382
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
Chlorophyta
|
Chlorophyta
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
7.3109800
|
3.5095311
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2.7354300
|
3.5095087
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.1762440
|
0.0000000
|
0.1715510
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4802380
|
0.3509509
|
0.1715510
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4948380
|
0.0000000
|
0.1715510
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.3854400
|
1.0528526
|
0.5907810
|
1.7547521
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.5377000
|
0.7019017
|
0.5907810
|
1.7547521
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.5663800
|
1.7547543
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
2.5591800
|
1.7547767
|
6.0027100
|
1.4038035
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.3387200
|
2.1057276
|
6.0027100
|
1.4038035
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
4.2710400
|
1.4038035
|
6.0027100
|
1.4038035
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
4.3143200
|
3.5095311
|
2.7354300
|
3.5095087
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.2363100
|
1.4038258
|
0.5907810
|
1.7547521
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.7316700
|
1.4038035
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.7389700
|
5.2642854
|
25.2498000
|
12.6342313
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
7.8397100
|
2.4566784
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
8.7329200
|
4.2113657
|
7.3109800
|
3.5095311
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
10.5783000
|
4.5622495
|
2.7354300
|
3.5095087
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
12.9930000
|
4.2114104
|
7.9606800
|
3.5095311
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
13.6401000
|
6.3171156
|
25.2498000
|
12.6342313
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
13.7486000
|
8.4228209
|
20.8014000
|
8.7738835
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
14.7148000
|
4.9133122
|
7.9606800
|
3.5095311
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
14.8430000
|
3.8605714
|
20.8014000
|
8.7738835
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
15.6242000
|
6.3171156
|
7.3109800
|
3.5095311
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Green Filamentous spp
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
16.5883000
|
5.2641512
|
7.9606800
|
3.5095311
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
18.9139000
|
6.6679547
|
20.8014000
|
8.7738835
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
22.5769000
|
11.2304278
|
25.2498000
|
12.6342313
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.1585000
|
0.4551293
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0999400
|
0.2600100
|
0.1585000
|
0.4551293
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.1008000
|
0.0000000
|
0.1585000
|
0.4551293
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.1057960
|
0.2600077
|
0.6285690
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.1804640
|
0.1950053
|
0.3253630
|
0.4550130
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2005940
|
0.3250102
|
0.4327020
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2971930
|
0.2600077
|
0.3253630
|
0.4550130
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.3374540
|
0.4550130
|
0.6285690
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.3539180
|
0.3900127
|
0.3253630
|
0.4550130
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4031820
|
0.4550152
|
0.4327020
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.5232560
|
0.4550130
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.5232560
|
0.4550130
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.6098220
|
0.5850180
|
0.3186420
|
0.5200155
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.8038560
|
0.1508049
|
0.6285690
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.8124100
|
0.7146250
|
0.3186420
|
0.5200155
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.9568580
|
0.5190853
|
0.4327020
|
0.3900127
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.3660000
|
0.4539218
|
0.3186420
|
0.5200155
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.1686000
|
2.4050924
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.1686000
|
2.4050924
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
5.9302300
|
5.2001550
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
5.9302300
|
5.2001550
|
2.4418600
|
3.4451099
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
BranchingCorralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2.4108700
|
2.8023746
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2460780
|
1.0508938
|
0.5548880
|
1.0508893
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.7593750
|
1.4011985
|
3.2711000
|
2.8023969
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.9954020
|
1.0509028
|
2.4108700
|
2.8023746
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.6462900
|
1.7514897
|
0.5548880
|
1.0508893
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.8656900
|
2.1017697
|
3.2711000
|
2.8023969
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
2.6011500
|
5.2544691
|
0.5548880
|
1.0508893
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.2035200
|
3.1526770
|
2.4108700
|
2.8023746
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.5937800
|
2.1017697
|
3.2711000
|
2.8023969
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
4.1815900
|
2.4520721
|
6.2233400
|
1.7514897
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
5.6057200
|
1.4011873
|
6.2233400
|
1.7514897
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.1363500
|
2.4520721
|
8.6477300
|
3.5029570
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.2278500
|
2.4520721
|
6.2233400
|
1.7514897
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
6.7775400
|
1.7514897
|
8.6477300
|
3.5029570
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
8.0259500
|
3.8532818
|
8.6477300
|
3.5029570
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
13.1527000
|
2.4520721
|
11.5806000
|
3.1526322
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
14.2531000
|
4.9041443
|
11.5806000
|
3.1526322
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
14.6992000
|
2.4520721
|
15.9434000
|
4.2035842
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
15.1553000
|
4.5537524
|
15.9434000
|
4.2035842
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
15.8249000
|
5.9550962
|
20.9994000
|
5.9550962
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
17.2150000
|
3.8534159
|
11.5806000
|
3.1526322
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
18.2066000
|
3.5030241
|
20.0910000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
19.1220000
|
5.2543125
|
24.1402000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
20.2955000
|
8.4071684
|
29.2302000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
20.6965000
|
6.6556563
|
20.9994000
|
5.9550962
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
21.1176000
|
4.9041443
|
15.9434000
|
4.2035842
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
24.1881000
|
7.0067190
|
27.7960000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
27.1507000
|
8.0567765
|
20.0910000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
28.1381000
|
8.4071684
|
29.2302000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
28.9027000
|
5.9550962
|
27.7960000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
29.1626000
|
8.0570001
|
24.1402000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
29.4954000
|
9.8082886
|
20.0910000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
35.0363000
|
15.4129930
|
29.2302000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
35.7305000
|
10.8592405
|
20.9994000
|
5.9550962
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
41.2738000
|
7.3562164
|
27.7960000
|
3.8534159
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
44.8236000
|
20.3171372
|
24.1402000
|
10.1586804
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.0784740
|
0.0000000
|
0.3380670
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2094790
|
0.0000000
|
0.3380670
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2439090
|
0.4345396
|
0.2120030
|
0.2172698
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.2912290
|
0.2172698
|
0.6141490
|
0.2896938
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.3251760
|
0.2172698
|
1.0371400
|
1.3760315
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4068730
|
0.2896916
|
0.2120030
|
0.2172698
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4073020
|
0.2896938
|
0.2120030
|
0.2172698
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4731540
|
0.3621156
|
0.5059720
|
0.4345396
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.4860450
|
0.2896916
|
1.0371400
|
1.3760315
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.5328820
|
0.2896938
|
0.3380670
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.6435300
|
0.6518093
|
0.4820700
|
0.3621156
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.6494920
|
0.4345396
|
1.0371400
|
1.3760315
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 1 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.7745890
|
0.2896916
|
0.4820700
|
0.3621156
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.8179350
|
0.4345463
|
3.4742900
|
1.2312014
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.8872240
|
0.4345485
|
0.4975390
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
0.8956570
|
0.5069680
|
0.5059720
|
0.4345396
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.0067900
|
0.5069613
|
1.4283200
|
0.5069613
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.0077500
|
0.8690925
|
1.4283200
|
0.5069613
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.1124400
|
0.5793876
|
0.4975390
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.2534400
|
0.7242177
|
1.7721900
|
0.7242401
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.2689100
|
0.7242177
|
1.7552200
|
1.0863489
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.4457800
|
0.9414964
|
0.5059720
|
0.4345396
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.4557200
|
0.8690702
|
0.6141490
|
0.2896938
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.5265100
|
0.9414964
|
1.4283200
|
0.5069613
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.121
|
17.5506
|
Site 2 Porto Cesaro, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.6316300
|
0.5069613
|
0.4975390
|
0.2172698
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.8428800
|
0.8690702
|
0.4820700
|
0.3621156
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 1 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
1.9425700
|
1.0139227
|
0.6141490
|
0.2896938
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.4302
|
17.4758
|
Site 2 Guaceto, Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
2.0323200
|
0.9414964
|
1.7721900
|
0.7242401
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
2.1767500
|
0.7242401
|
1.7552200
|
1.0863489
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
2.7622700
|
0.9415188
|
3.4742900
|
1.2312014
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.2162000
|
0.8690702
|
3.4742900
|
1.2312014
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.4907800
|
1.8829928
|
3.0701600
|
1.2311790
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
limestonevsconcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.5864400
|
1.3760315
|
1.7721900
|
0.7242401
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.7190000
|
1.2312014
|
3.0701600
|
1.2311790
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
3.7642800
|
1.3036276
|
1.7552200
|
1.0863489
|
10
|
10
|
10
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.015
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 1 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
Significant
|
Fig 3A
|
|
|
Guarnieri et al 2009
|
2009
|
5.8237300
|
2.3899542
|
3.0701600
|
1.2311790
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x10x3cm
|
0.0126
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
granitevsconcrete
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
5m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
9.000000
|
40.0821
|
18.303
|
Site 2 Otranto , Italy
|
Mediterranean
|
Rocky subtidal
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3A
|
Grazers in background substrate (sea urchins) - removed. 9cm x 14cm of each tile considered for counts.
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
2.9000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.930000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsSteel
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.930000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
0.1000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.930000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsMetal
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.930000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.4000000
|
NA
|
4.9000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.530000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.4000000
|
NA
|
0.8000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.530000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.4000000
|
NA
|
0.3000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsSteel
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.530000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.4000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsMetal
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.530000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.9000000
|
NA
|
2.1000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.360000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.9000000
|
NA
|
0.2000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.360000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.9000000
|
NA
|
0.1000000
|
NA
|
9
|
9
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsSteel
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.360000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hanson1976
|
1976
|
0.9000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
9
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x10cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsMetal
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_pine
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal_nickel
|
Metal
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.360000
|
48.42
|
-122.58
|
USA
|
Puget sound
|
tiles
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Table 2
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
18.2200000
|
NA
|
12.4700000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete_2
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_2
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
18.2200000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
sandstonevsenamelmetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Enamelled Metal
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
18.2200000
|
NA
|
6.5600000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
sandstonevsrustymetal
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Rusty metal
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
18.2200000
|
NA
|
24.0900000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
sandstonevsconcrete_6
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_6
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
8.3700000
|
NA
|
12.4700000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_3vsconcrete_2
|
Wood_3
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete_2
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
8.3700000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_3vsenamelmetal
|
Wood_3
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Enamelled Metal
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
8.3700000
|
NA
|
6.5600000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_3vsrustymetal
|
Wood_3
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Rusty metal
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
8.3700000
|
NA
|
24.0900000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_3vsconcrete_6
|
Wood_3
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete_6
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
15.6500000
|
NA
|
12.4700000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_5vsconcrete_2
|
Wood_5
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete_2
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
15.6500000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_5vsenamelmetal
|
Wood_5
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Enamelled Metal
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal_enamelled
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
15.6500000
|
NA
|
6.5600000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_5vsrustymetal
|
Wood_5
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Rusty metal
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Hills 1996
|
1996
|
15.6500000
|
NA
|
24.0900000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Semibalanus balanoides
|
Thoracica
|
|
50x50cm, but 10x10 cm quadrats
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
available pieces of material
|
|
wood_5vsconcrete_6
|
Wood_5
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete_6
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
55.76649
|
-4.862936
|
UK
|
Firth of Clyde UK
|
Pier
|
Exposed
|
Nothing on enamelled metal, roughness also measured
|
Table 1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Hixon&Brostoff1985
|
1985
|
13.3000000
|
13.4000000
|
38.6000000
|
15.5000000
|
7
|
7
|
7
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Biogenic
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
ALL
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
CoralvsPlastic
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
21.47
|
-157.81
|
Hawaii
|
Hawaii
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Table
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
8.2400000
|
4.1900000
|
12.3800000
|
1.6800000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
8.2400000
|
4.1900000
|
11.7300000
|
3.6300000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
8.2400000
|
4.1900000
|
4.1000000
|
0.0000000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
23.9300000
|
10.9600000
|
47.1700000
|
5.0600000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
23.9300000
|
10.9600000
|
34.0500000
|
8.1600000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
23.9300000
|
10.9600000
|
33.3000000
|
0.2900000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPVC
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
23.9300000
|
10.9600000
|
30.4900000
|
4.7800000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
37.9700000
|
2.2200000
|
52.9300000
|
4.1800000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
37.9700000
|
2.2200000
|
39.4500000
|
4.4600000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
37.9700000
|
2.2200000
|
38.5200000
|
8.6400000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
37.9700000
|
2.2200000
|
36.6600000
|
3.8700000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Horizontal
|
LimestonevsPVC
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
7.4800000
|
1.6900000
|
27.9600000
|
5.3300000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
7.4800000
|
1.6900000
|
23.0800000
|
1.1300000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
7.4800000
|
1.6900000
|
16.2400000
|
1.4100000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
7.4800000
|
1.6900000
|
15.8200000
|
3.9400000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPVC
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Back
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
32.3800000
|
17.1500000
|
34.8600000
|
7.4700000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
32.3800000
|
17.1500000
|
35.9700000
|
10.2400000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
32.3800000
|
17.1500000
|
33.7600000
|
13.0000000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPVC
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
32.3800000
|
17.1500000
|
26.8400000
|
4.7000000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Crest
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
30.1900000
|
6.7300000
|
38.4600000
|
3.3600000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
limestonevsterracotta
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Terracotta
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
30.1900000
|
6.7300000
|
35.5200000
|
3.3500000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPVC
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
30.1900000
|
6.7300000
|
22.7700000
|
1.1200000
|
16
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPoly
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Polycarbonate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Kennedy2017
|
2017
|
30.1900000
|
6.7300000
|
16.3400000
|
1.9500000
|
16
|
3
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
CCA
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
4.5X4.5 cm
|
0.2025
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
LimestonevsPorcelain
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Porcelain
|
Clay
|
Clay_porcelain
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-23.44
|
151.92
|
Australia
|
Great Barrier Reef
|
Reef Slope
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
29.6666667
|
35.5668130
|
36.0000000
|
50.2045471
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
29.6666667
|
35.5668130
|
16.0000000
|
20.6746362
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
8.6666667
|
14.5732937
|
9.8833333
|
16.2757351
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
8.6666667
|
14.5732937
|
11.6666667
|
18.5027698
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
55.9166667
|
38.8269244
|
63.0000000
|
61.3381014
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
55.9166667
|
38.8269244
|
48.0000000
|
56.1310314
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
1.3333333
|
3.2659863
|
5.0000000
|
11.6472511
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
1.3333333
|
3.2659863
|
4.6666667
|
10.8307545
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
65.5833333
|
63.0371947
|
66.0833333
|
71.0974694
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
65.5833333
|
63.0371947
|
86.0000000
|
42.6426776
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
92.3333333
|
12.7948897
|
97.0000000
|
26.7967408
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
92.3333333
|
12.7948897
|
93.0000000
|
16.2918881
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
17.0000000
|
25.2938202
|
12.3333333
|
19.6597197
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
17.0000000
|
25.2938202
|
11.9500000
|
16.9447897
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
79.0000000
|
40.6406862
|
75.6666667
|
61.1772358
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
79.0000000
|
40.6406862
|
56.3500000
|
41.6177207
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
17.9333333
|
18.8673662
|
7.3166667
|
10.8029504
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
17.9333333
|
18.8673662
|
21.3333333
|
22.2817692
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
2.0000000
|
2.1908902
|
0.3333333
|
0.8164966
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
2.0000000
|
2.1908902
|
2.3333333
|
3.3463187
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Ascidian
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
63.0000000
|
67.5459077
|
85.5000000
|
127.0235341
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
63.0000000
|
67.5459077
|
72.9166667
|
65.8502122
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
74.1666667
|
75.3236953
|
87.6666667
|
74.2269110
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
74.1666667
|
75.3236953
|
81.8333333
|
80.7343433
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
72.8333333
|
72.5480354
|
76.3333333
|
76.2669587
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
72.8333333
|
72.5480354
|
82.0000000
|
59.7454978
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
43.6666667
|
28.7517336
|
63.9166667
|
49.1319725
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
43.6666667
|
28.7517336
|
62.3333333
|
69.2646155
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
72.6666667
|
100.0274392
|
61.3333333
|
95.7287948
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
72.6666667
|
100.0274392
|
73.5000000
|
72.0010187
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
48.2948718
|
45.0596036
|
58.3333333
|
64.2578342
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
48.2948718
|
45.0596036
|
43.5000000
|
38.0520733
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
75.5000000
|
59.0274766
|
80.7000000
|
80.3491548
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
75.5000000
|
59.0274766
|
73.9000000
|
71.1137895
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
70.1666667
|
71.6280950
|
78.1666667
|
100.5236872
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
70.1666667
|
71.6280950
|
60.6666667
|
62.4954077
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
38.1666667
|
43.6215899
|
36.0000000
|
49.6165686
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
38.1666667
|
43.6215899
|
52.1666667
|
43.1807101
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
28.9166667
|
33.5397819
|
46.4166667
|
47.3884803
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
28.9166667
|
33.5397819
|
32.0833333
|
31.1637562
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2012_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
60.5000000
|
89.1315515
|
75.0000000
|
107.2659898
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
60.5000000
|
89.1315515
|
63.6666667
|
106.4364800
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_February
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
23.6666667
|
26.2561975
|
29.6666667
|
30.3092973
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
23.6666667
|
26.2561975
|
30.6666667
|
38.6707029
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.071232
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2013_April
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
49.6666667
|
50.2448480
|
42.3333333
|
47.1238033
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
49.6666667
|
50.2448480
|
40.7166667
|
47.9714074
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
69.2166667
|
42.1027825
|
73.5166667
|
55.4169516
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
69.2166667
|
42.1027825
|
72.1166667
|
39.7575794
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_September
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
44.6666667
|
50.9340747
|
42.3333333
|
68.7474341
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
44.6666667
|
50.9340747
|
64.3333333
|
80.3936477
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
42.0000000
|
61.1215788
|
42.5166667
|
75.8908558
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
42.0000000
|
61.1215788
|
38.0000000
|
48.7927223
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
64.6666667
|
72.9896596
|
57.6666667
|
79.2336090
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
64.6666667
|
72.9896596
|
64.3333333
|
78.5840437
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
1.0000000
|
2.4494897
|
17.0000000
|
35.9197253
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
1.0000000
|
2.4494897
|
3.3333333
|
6.4205733
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
up facing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
26.0000000
|
49.8273933
|
24.0000000
|
36.1794973
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
26.0000000
|
49.8273933
|
25.0000000
|
49.6423250
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
North Haven Harbour
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
73.4500000
|
63.0458924
|
70.4500000
|
60.4179280
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
73.4500000
|
63.0458924
|
92.6666667
|
51.2450081
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_June
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
94.0000000
|
24.5438140
|
83.3333333
|
63.8854141
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
94.0000000
|
24.5438140
|
84.0000000
|
30.3930633
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
87.6666667
|
44.4090154
|
86.0000000
|
87.3286560
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
87.6666667
|
44.4090154
|
71.3333333
|
57.2040964
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
34°47’9"S
|
138°29’15"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2015_December
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
58.3000000
|
59.2792519
|
60.5333333
|
67.2722681
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
58.3000000
|
59.2792519
|
43.7333333
|
50.8856875
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
45.6666667
|
73.7824015
|
58.3333333
|
94.7464122
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvsacrylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
Lee2018
|
2018
|
45.6666667
|
73.7824015
|
34.3333333
|
48.7765680
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
Bryozoan
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.01
|
y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
woodvscement
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Cement
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
|
1
|
Y
|
2.991779
|
35°30’5"S
|
138°14’38"E
|
Wirrina Cove
|
|
2016_March
|
|
Australia
|
Original dataset
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
5.0000000
|
0.2828427
|
44.8700000
|
6.8730779
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
5.0000000
|
0.2828427
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
24.3300000
|
27.5205959
|
44.8700000
|
6.8730779
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
24.3300000
|
27.5205959
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
41.6200000
|
55.8048672
|
51.3520000
|
61.1619082
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
41.6200000
|
55.8048672
|
26.4900000
|
33.6441406
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
49.1900000
|
53.5138412
|
51.3520000
|
61.1619082
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
49.1900000
|
53.5138412
|
26.4900000
|
33.6441406
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site1
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
52.1500000
|
61.5890006
|
56.3900000
|
55.4937402
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
52.1500000
|
61.5890006
|
53.1800000
|
65.5063722
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
53.2000000
|
63.8658845
|
56.3900000
|
55.4937402
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
53.2000000
|
63.8658845
|
53.1800000
|
65.5063722
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
71.0600000
|
30.4197337
|
65.6700000
|
39.5272691
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
71.0600000
|
30.4197337
|
49.5000000
|
62.3385338
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.3300000
|
14.5239733
|
94.7000000
|
5.3457273
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.3300000
|
14.5239733
|
94.6500000
|
3.0547013
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.5300000
|
30.4197337
|
65.6700000
|
39.5272691
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.5300000
|
30.4197337
|
49.5000000
|
62.3385338
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site2
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.8500000
|
19.8697006
|
94.7000000
|
5.3457273
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
77.8500000
|
19.8697006
|
94.6500000
|
3.0547013
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
78.8400000
|
12.7137799
|
13.2300000
|
8.2307229
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
87.8300000
|
0.2404163
|
52.3800000
|
5.9962655
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
87.8300000
|
0.2404163
|
13.2300000
|
8.2307229
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
10.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
95.5900000
|
6.1235447
|
98.3100000
|
2.3900209
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
95.5900000
|
6.1235447
|
97.7700000
|
0.3252691
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
96.3000000
|
0.9899495
|
98.4200000
|
2.2344574
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
96.3000000
|
0.9899495
|
97.3600000
|
3.7335238
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Siltstone
|
Rock_siltstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
98.9800000
|
1.4424978
|
98.4200000
|
2.2344574
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
98.9800000
|
1.4424978
|
97.3600000
|
3.7335238
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
99.3500000
|
0.9192388
|
98.3100000
|
2.3900209
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
McGuiness 1989
|
1989
|
99.3500000
|
0.9192388
|
97.7700000
|
0.3252691
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/invertebrates
|
|
|
|
10x13cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPersplexs
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
9.4
|
-79.86
|
Site3
|
Panama
|
sheltered
|
sheltered
|
|
Figure1
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
300.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
107.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
0.930000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
300.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
400.0000000
|
5.7157677
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
0.930000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
300.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
400.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
0.930000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
300.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
32.0000000
|
15.9348674
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
0.930000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
300.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
10.0000000
|
0.5196152
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
0.930000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
200.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
558.0000000
|
166.4500826
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.860000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
200.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
550.0000000
|
173.0318757
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.860000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
200.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
500.0000000
|
173.0318757
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.860000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
200.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
400.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.860000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
200.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
54.0000000
|
83.4848489
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
1.860000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
6.0000000
|
7.7942286
|
12.0000000
|
1.3856406
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
2.800000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
6.0000000
|
7.7942286
|
11.0000000
|
10.0458947
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
2.800000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
6.0000000
|
7.7942286
|
4.0000000
|
3.9837169
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
2.800000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
6.0000000
|
7.7942286
|
2.0000000
|
1.5588457
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
2.800000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
6.0000000
|
7.7942286
|
3.0000000
|
4.1569219
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
2.800000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
0.3000000
|
0.5196152
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
3.730000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
0.3000000
|
0.5196152
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
3.730000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
0.3000000
|
0.5196152
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
3.730000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
0.3000000
|
0.5196152
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
3.730000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
0.3000000
|
0.5196152
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
3.730000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
833.0000000
|
152.7668812
|
567.0000000
|
57.6772919
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
4.660000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
833.0000000
|
152.7668812
|
700.0000000
|
200.0518683
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
4.660000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
833.0000000
|
152.7668812
|
700.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
4.660000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
833.0000000
|
152.7668812
|
400.0000000
|
99.9393316
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
4.660000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
833.0000000
|
152.7668812
|
33.0000000
|
5.7157677
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
NA
|
4.660000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
1383.0000000
|
236.2517302
|
1050.0000000
|
50.0562683
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
5.600000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
1383.0000000
|
236.2517302
|
1257.0000000
|
66.1643408
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsConcrete
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
5.600000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
1383.0000000
|
236.2517302
|
1130.0000000
|
50.0562683
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsBrick
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Brick
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
5.600000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
1383.0000000
|
236.2517302
|
960.0000000
|
147.2243186
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsFibre
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
5.600000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Norris1991
|
1991
|
1383.0000000
|
236.2517302
|
304.0000000
|
16.4544827
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Balanus eburneus <1mm
|
Amphibalanus eburneus
|
Thoracica
|
|
10x15cm
|
0.013
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
WoodvsPlexi
|
Wood_oak salt treated
|
Wood_oak
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plexi_methyl methacrylate
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
mid
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
5.600000
|
34.06
|
-77.89
|
USA
|
harbour
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
25.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
4.1000000
|
6.3739470
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
6.6700000
|
3.8451528
|
3.6600000
|
4.9363448
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
13.0200000
|
2.4768327
|
4.1300000
|
6.8589212
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
26.6700000
|
12.3668428
|
10.6400000
|
8.7988181
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
5.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
S
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
25.0000000
|
NA
|
17.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Barnacles
|
Thoracica
|
Thoracica
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
5.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
15.0000000
|
NA
|
35.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
20.0000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
4.2600000
|
3.4121401
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
5.2500000
|
3.3948196
|
3.3000000
|
4.0703194
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
63.9700000
|
50.9396142
|
12.6000000
|
2.0438200
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
Mollusc
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
4.0000000
|
3.8971143
|
1.3000000
|
2.3382686
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
4.1500000
|
3.5853452
|
1.4000000
|
3.1003709
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
6.6100000
|
4.8324218
|
2.6800000
|
2.2343455
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
6.8000000
|
4.0000000
|
6.8000000
|
4.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
19.2300000
|
10.0000000
|
1.0200000
|
3.4641016
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
26.3200000
|
21.0270968
|
26.3200000
|
21.0270968
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
27.9200000
|
6.9282032
|
17.5000000
|
9.5262794
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
159.9200000
|
91.1751545
|
55.6700000
|
64.8653027
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrate
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
7.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
0.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
18.0000000
|
NA
|
40.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
20.0000000
|
NA
|
25.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
20.0000000
|
NA
|
18.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
2.6000000
|
2.8752043
|
7.0000000
|
5.7504087
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Hydrozoa
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
6.6400000
|
6.0621778
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
Sponge
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
59.7200000
|
96.4232685
|
41.5000000
|
35.0567084
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
30.0000000
|
NA
|
50.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
60.0000000
|
NA
|
50.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
60.0000000
|
NA
|
40.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
1.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
80.0000000
|
NA
|
75.0000000
|
NA
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 4
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
20.5900000
|
0.7101408
|
0.7500000
|
0.4330127
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
2.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
74.6600000
|
17.1819440
|
46.8700000
|
30.9344274
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
3.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Olaliaet2009
|
2009
|
400.6000000
|
109.8986237
|
77.1400000
|
13.7351629
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Wood
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Mobile
|
Polychaete
|
|
|
|
15x15cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
vertical
|
WoodvsPlastic
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_vitex parviflora molave
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Plastic_polypropylene
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
10.3
|
123.96
|
Philippines
|
Mactan Island
|
tile
|
sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure 5
|
Grazers excluded
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
0.0180083
|
0.0099601
|
0.1207980
|
0.0398400
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea sikema
|
Crassostrea sikamea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
ClamvsBrick
|
Shell_clam
|
Biogenic_clam
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
0.0314844
|
0.0298808
|
0.1207980
|
0.0398400
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea sikema
|
Crassostrea sikamea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
OystervsBrick
|
Shell_oyster
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
0.1028600
|
0.0298806
|
0.1207980
|
0.0398400
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea sikema
|
Crassostrea sikamea
|
Crassostrea
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.0001
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
LimestonevsBrick
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
43.0000000
|
11.4039467
|
38.6000000
|
10.9567331
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Clay
|
Benthic_Biogenic
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.066
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
OystervsBrick
|
Shell_oyster
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Table 4
|
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
52.6000000
|
21.2426458
|
38.6000000
|
10.9567331
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Clay
|
Benthic_Rock
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.066
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
LimestonevsBrick
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Table 4
|
|
|
Quanetal2017
|
2017
|
71.6000000
|
62.3862966
|
38.6000000
|
10.9567331
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Clay
|
Benthic_Biogenic
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
60x11cm
|
0.066
|
Y
|
Bag
|
mixed
|
ClamvsBrick
|
Shell_clam
|
Biogenic_clam
|
Biogenic_Clay
|
Biogenic
|
Brick fragments
|
Clay
|
Clay_brick
|
Clay
|
Na
|
intertidal
|
Final
|
36.000000
|
29.64
|
121.83
|
China
|
harbour
|
Harbour
|
sheltered
|
Significant - substrates were all pieces and biogenic can be included.
|
Table 4
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
10.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvstyre
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
12.0000000
|
NA
|
9.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
rockvstyre
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
4.9645400
|
13.0388511
|
3.5461000
|
8.0239083
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Chapman & Clynick 2006
|
2006
|
11.0000000
|
NA
|
9.0000000
|
NA
|
1
|
1
|
1
|
Richness
|
Fish
|
Fish_Metal
|
Fish_Wood
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
all
|
|
|
|
1.5mx1.5mx0.8m
|
NA
|
Y
|
Reef
|
Mixed (vertical and horizontal)
|
woodvsmetal
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Metal
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal_unclassified
|
Metal
|
6 m
|
subtidal
|
NA
|
13.000000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure6
|
Replicates - Fish are counted over the whole reef, no quadrats used.. All replicates for each substrate have been summed (not averaged), therefore the replicate for the mean and control in this case is 1. Size of sampled area in m2 - this is NA as the area above each reef was included too.
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
8.1560300
|
17.0508052
|
2.8368800
|
6.0179313
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
9.2198600
|
17.0507204
|
6.0283700
|
7.0209198
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
0.8421050
|
3.9697116
|
2.3157900
|
4.7636652
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
1.1228100
|
2.0000000
|
0.2105260
|
1.5000000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
3.7894700
|
6.1530735
|
0.4210530
|
3.1757778
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.1
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
14.2857000
|
4.9732234
|
15.6044000
|
4.3515351
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Canopy
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
|
1500m2
|
100
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.B.4
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
17.3626000
|
3.7298468
|
16.4835000
|
6.2163171
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Canopy
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
|
1500m2
|
100
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.B.4
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
18.4615000
|
3.1081586
|
17.8022000
|
3.7298468
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Canopy_Algae
|
Canopy
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
Macrocystis
|
|
1500m2
|
100
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.B.4
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.4773200
|
1.5073670
|
7.7968400
|
2.3995691
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.4773200
|
1.5073670
|
7.5400000
|
1.0462506
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
570.2700000
|
54.5400000
|
538.2100000
|
69.6900000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
160
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.c.2
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
624.8100000
|
3.0300000
|
695.7600000
|
45.4400000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
160
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.c.2
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
624.8100000
|
3.0300000
|
695.7600000
|
45.4400000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
160
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.c.2
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
9.6469400
|
2.0099533
|
7.0197200
|
1.7634367
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Not Measured
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
9.6469400
|
2.0099533
|
7.0037300
|
1.6200925
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Not Measured
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
9.6469400
|
2.0099533
|
6.9127800
|
2.1757103
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
4.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 4
|
Sheltered
|
Not Measured
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
44.8399000
|
9.6627556
|
44.4128000
|
10.8707768
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
68.3274000
|
10.8707768
|
62.3488000
|
12.0785152
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
81.9929000
|
18.1180556
|
75.1601000
|
19.3260769
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
111.0320000
|
21.1368359
|
104.6260000
|
57.3746442
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
120.6410000
|
45.2944320
|
152.6690000
|
42.2765002
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
199.6440000
|
87.5709322
|
178.2920000
|
96.6303843
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock_quarried rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete_recycled rubble
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.9
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.5000000
|
2.5000000
|
46.5000000
|
46.5000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
58.5000000
|
8.7000000
|
43.5000000
|
19.1000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
18.2000000
|
13.9000000
|
11.0000000
|
6.0000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
97.6000000
|
0.9000000
|
96.3000000
|
2.3000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
73.0000000
|
24.4000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.5000000
|
2.5000000
|
29.0000000
|
29.0000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
58.5000000
|
8.7000000
|
56.0000000
|
5.5000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
18.2000000
|
13.9000000
|
9.6000000
|
8.4000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
97.6000000
|
0.9000000
|
90.2000000
|
3.8000000
|
5
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
28.7000000
|
0.3000000
|
73.0000000
|
24.4000000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
29.0000000
|
29.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
7.3000000
|
7.3000000
|
3
|
5
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
73.8000000
|
18.6000000
|
90.2000000
|
3.8000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
28.7000000
|
0.3000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
46.5000000
|
46.5000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.0000000
|
2.0000000
|
15.0000000
|
9.6000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
73.8000000
|
18.6000000
|
96.3000000
|
2.3000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Wood
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.5000000
|
1.5000000
|
2.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.5000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
25.5000000
|
9.5000000
|
15.5000000
|
4.7000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
65.8000000
|
11.4000000
|
68.4000000
|
6.6000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.4000000
|
0.7000000
|
2.3000000
|
1.4000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.5000000
|
1.5000000
|
2.8000000
|
1.7000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.5000000
|
1.5000000
|
3.3000000
|
2.8000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
25.5000000
|
9.5000000
|
24.2000000
|
5.6000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
65.8000000
|
11.4000000
|
56.8000000
|
11.5000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.4000000
|
0.7000000
|
7.8000000
|
4.3000000
|
5
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
8.3000000
|
3.2000000
|
2.8000000
|
1.7000000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
9.3000000
|
3.2000000
|
3.3000000
|
2.8000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
7.0000000
|
5.6000000
|
3
|
5
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
6.6000000
|
2.7000000
|
7.8000000
|
4.3000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
8.3000000
|
3.2000000
|
2.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
9.3000000
|
3.2000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
1.0000000
|
0.6000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
6.6000000
|
2.7000000
|
2.3000000
|
1.4000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Clay
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
6.6134100
|
1.0049277
|
5.7790900
|
0.8793178
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.4773200
|
1.5073670
|
5.1558200
|
1.6201170
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 12
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Glasby et al 2007
|
2007
|
5.2640000
|
0.9391486
|
5.0680000
|
0.5634891
|
15
|
15
|
15
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x15cm panels
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
sandstonevsconcrete
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.500000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef, seawall, pontoon, piling
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
Glasby et al 2007
|
2007
|
3.7240000
|
0.6260990
|
5.0680000
|
0.5634891
|
15
|
15
|
15
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
15x15cm panels
|
0.0225
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Vertical
|
woodvsconcrete
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
7.500000
|
-33.85
|
151.54
|
Australia
|
Sydney harbour
|
Reef, seawall, pontoon, piling
|
Sheltered
|
NS
|
Figure 4
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
6.6134100
|
1.0049277
|
4.6351100
|
1.2701094
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
4.0000000
|
0.4000000
|
4.6000000
|
0.5000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.6000000
|
0.2000000
|
4.6000000
|
0.9000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
6.6134100
|
1.0049277
|
4.3565600
|
0.0010000
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 2
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.2228800
|
1.0049277
|
4.2366900
|
0.7536835
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Concrete
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsconcrete
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Concrete
|
Wood
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Not Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.6000000
|
0.2000000
|
4.2000000
|
0.6000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
4.9650300
|
2.9669069
|
4.1258700
|
2.3735029
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteHighvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_high
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
4.0000000
|
0.4000000
|
3.0000000
|
0.9000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Liberty State Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Hixon&Brostoff1985
|
1985
|
3.0000000
|
0.0010000
|
3.0000000
|
0.0010000
|
7
|
7
|
7
|
Richness
|
Benthic
|
Benthic_Polymer
|
Benthic_Biogenic
|
Benthic
|
N
|
|
Benthic
|
ALL
|
|
|
|
NA
|
NA
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
CoralvsPlastic
|
Coral
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
21.47
|
-157.81
|
Hawaii
|
Hawaii
|
Reef
|
Exposed
|
NS
|
Table
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
3.4265700
|
2.7690867
|
2.9370600
|
2.1757110
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteMedvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_med
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.3
|
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.2228800
|
1.0049277
|
2.5680500
|
1.2561473
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsfiberglass
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reed 2005
|
2005
|
3.3566400
|
3.3624625
|
2.5174800
|
2.7690867
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
Understorey algae
|
|
|
|
1500m2
|
80
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
ConcreteLowvsRock
|
Rock
|
Rock_unclassified
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
n/a
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
60.000000
|
33.425076
|
-117.629032
|
USA
|
North pacific
|
Reef_low
|
Exposed
|
Experiment over 5 years in total 2000-2004, San Mateo (SM) and Barn (B) reefs used as natural reef controls
|
FigIII.D.3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.2000000
|
0.2000000
|
1.8000000
|
0.4000000
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.6000000
|
0.2000000
|
1.8000000
|
0.4000000
|
5
|
3
|
3
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reyes and Yap 2001
|
2001
|
2.9599200
|
2.6244900
|
0.4109820
|
1.0349315
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Scleractinian corals
|
Scleractinia
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RubbervsCoralAway
|
Coral_rubble crushed
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
12m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.500000
|
9.872537
|
122.378348
|
Philippines
|
Sulu
|
outside_Reef
|
NA
|
Some plates placed within reef and others placed away from. Conclusions: coral larvae settle most in proximity to live colonies and use or crushed coral or concrete is preferred to rubber
|
Fig1
|
|
|
Reyes and Yap 2001
|
2001
|
7.7447700
|
4.3000000
|
6.9397900
|
2.5000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Scleractinian corals
|
Scleractinia
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsCoralWithin
|
Coral_rubble crushed
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
12m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.500000
|
9.872537
|
122.378348
|
Philippines
|
Sulu
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Some plates placed within reef and others placed away from. Conclusions: coral larvae settle most in proximity to live colonies and use or crushed coral or concrete is preferred to rubber
|
Fig1
|
|
|
Reyes and Yap 2001
|
2001
|
7.7447700
|
4.4000000
|
0.5007070
|
4.0000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Scleractinian corals
|
Scleractinia
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
RubbervsCoralWithin
|
Coral_rubble crushed
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
12m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.500000
|
9.872537
|
122.378348
|
Philippines
|
Sulu
|
Reef
|
NA
|
Some plates placed within reef and others placed away from. Conclusions: coral larvae settle most in proximity to live colonies and use or crushed coral or concrete is preferred to rubber
|
Fig1
|
|
|
Reyes and Yap 2001
|
2001
|
2.9599200
|
2.6244900
|
2.1000000
|
0.6000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Corals
|
Corals
|
Scleractinian corals
|
Scleractinia
|
Anthozoa
|
|
10cmx10cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsCoralWithin
|
Coral_rubble crushed
|
Biogenic_coral
|
Biogenic_Concrete
|
Biogenic
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
12m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
4.500000
|
9.872537
|
122.378348
|
Philippines
|
Sulu
|
outside_Reef
|
NA
|
Some plates placed within reef and others placed away from. Conclusions: coral larvae settle most in proximity to live colonies and use or crushed coral or concrete is preferred to rubber
|
Fig1
|
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
0.7000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.1000000
|
2.3000000
|
12
|
18
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsFibreglass
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.3000000
|
3.1500000
|
1.5000000
|
2.0500000
|
12
|
17
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsFibreglass
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
0.7000000
|
1.5500000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
8
|
14
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsFibreglass
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
0.7000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2000000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.3000000
|
3.1500000
|
0.3000000
|
0.4500000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
0.7000000
|
1.5500000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsPVC
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
0.7000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2500000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsSteel
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.3000000
|
3.1500000
|
0.1500000
|
0.4000000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
GranitevsSteel
|
Granite
|
Rock_granite
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size).
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.0000000
|
2.5000000
|
0.1000000
|
2.3000000
|
12
|
18
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
6.6000000
|
11.4000000
|
1.5000000
|
2.0500000
|
12
|
17
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
5.2500000
|
8.4000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
8
|
14
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.0000000
|
2.5000000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2000000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
6.6000000
|
11.4000000
|
0.3000000
|
0.4500000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
5.2500000
|
8.4000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.0000000
|
2.5000000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2500000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
6.6000000
|
11.4000000
|
0.1500000
|
0.4000000
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
5.2500000
|
8.4000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CA
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.8500000
|
4.1500000
|
0.1000000
|
2.3000000
|
18
|
18
|
18
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
10.3500000
|
12.6500000
|
1.5000000
|
2.0500000
|
17
|
17
|
17
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.9000000
|
6.7500000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
14
|
14
|
14
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsFibreglass
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.8500000
|
4.1500000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2000000
|
18
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
10.3500000
|
12.6500000
|
0.3000000
|
0.4500000
|
17
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.9000000
|
6.7500000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
14
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsPVC
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
1.8500000
|
4.1500000
|
0.0500000
|
0.2500000
|
18
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis south china
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
10.3500000
|
12.6500000
|
0.1500000
|
0.4000000
|
17
|
12
|
12
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea ariakensis west coast
|
Crassostrea ariakensis
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
Tamburrietal.2008
|
2008
|
2.9000000
|
6.7500000
|
0.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
14
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
Y
|
Bivalves
|
Bivalve
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea virginica
|
Crassostrea
|
|
4.2x6cm
|
0.00252
|
Y
|
Tray
|
Horizontal
|
OystervsSteel
|
Oyster_CV
|
Biogenic_oyster
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Stainless Steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal_stainless steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
NA
|
Final
|
0.070000
|
37.25
|
-76.5
|
USA
|
USA
|
tray
|
NA
|
NS
|
Table 4_clean
|
mean control and treatment are % settled larvae from table 4, /100 * 50 - to account for how many individuals have settled. Standardising the area assuming the bits of each substrate are 4.2 * 6 cm (which is the well size). All materials of similar complexity - small ‘bits’ used.
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
71.2300000
|
26.6735824
|
75.9400000
|
28.7000819
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
marblevsaluminium
|
Marble
|
Rock_marble
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
71.2300000
|
26.6735824
|
92.5100000
|
12.8400000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
marblevspvc
|
Marble
|
Rock_marble
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
71.2300000
|
26.6735824
|
48.6600000
|
13.9200000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
marblevsrubber
|
Marble
|
Rock_marble
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
71.2300000
|
26.6735824
|
48.6600000
|
29.9600000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
marblevsstyrofoam
|
Marble
|
Rock_marble
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
60.4300000
|
38.5000000
|
75.9400000
|
28.7000819
|
4
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
shellvsaluminium
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Metal
|
Biogenic
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
60.4300000
|
38.5000000
|
92.5100000
|
12.8400000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
shellvspvc
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
60.4300000
|
38.5000000
|
48.6600000
|
13.9200000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
shellvsrubber
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
60.4300000
|
38.5000000
|
48.6600000
|
29.9600000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Biogenic
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
shellvsstyrofoam
|
Shell
|
Biogenic_shell unclassified
|
Biogenic_Polymer
|
Biogenic
|
Styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
80.7500000
|
20.3689175
|
75.9400000
|
28.7000819
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
slatevsaluminium
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
80.7500000
|
20.3689175
|
92.5100000
|
12.8400000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
slatevspvc
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
80.7500000
|
20.3689175
|
48.6600000
|
13.9200000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
slatevsrubber
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
80.7500000
|
20.3689175
|
48.6600000
|
29.9600000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
slatevsstyrofoam
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
59.8900000
|
43.5437573
|
75.9400000
|
28.7000819
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Metal
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsaluminium
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
59.8900000
|
43.5437573
|
92.5100000
|
12.8400000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvspvc
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
59.8900000
|
43.5437573
|
48.6600000
|
13.9200000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsrubber
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
TyrellandByers2007
|
2007
|
59.8900000
|
43.5437573
|
48.6600000
|
29.9600000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Wood
|
Invert
|
N
|
Invertebrates
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0.0068
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
woodvsstyrofoam
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer_styrofoam
|
Polymer
|
|
3
|
Y
|
5.000000
|
43.3222° N
|
70.5805° W
|
Wells, Maine
|
|
2004_May_
|
|
USA
|
Figure 4c
|
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
83.6025000
|
32.9259394
|
81.2752000
|
26.5794628
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
83.6025000
|
32.9259394
|
88.0612000
|
32.9249002
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
98.3119000
|
43.4668542
|
93.5321000
|
25.1281428
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
98.3119000
|
43.4668542
|
104.4893000
|
33.3592985
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
105.5714000
|
58.7435424
|
91.5660000
|
62.0361709
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
105.5714000
|
58.7435424
|
96.4366000
|
70.3500148
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_summer deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Summer deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
121.0540000
|
33.9655163
|
106.8356000
|
34.3105409
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Polymer
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
121.0540000
|
33.9655163
|
112.4108000
|
53.2009798
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Concrete
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
N
|
|
Algae
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
ConcretevsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_12
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure4a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Anderson & Underwood 1994
|
1994
|
5.2228800
|
1.0049277
|
1.5654200
|
0.8658701
|
6
|
6
|
6
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
All
|
|
|
|
10 x 10 cm
|
0.01
|
Y
|
Tiles
|
Downward facing
|
plywoodvsaluminim
|
plywood
|
Wood_plywood
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal_aluminium
|
Metal
|
low
|
Intertidal
|
Final
|
1.000000
|
-34.01666667
|
151.1833333
|
Australia
|
Tasman
|
Exp 1-Jan deployment 1
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Fig 3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.3000000
|
0.3000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
3
|
4
|
3
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.3000000
|
0.3000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.2000000
|
0.2000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.3000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.6000000
|
0.2000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.3000000
|
4
|
5
|
4
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
slatevsceramic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.0000000
|
1.0000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.0000000
|
1.0000000
|
1.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
4
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Gabion
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
1.3000000
|
0.9000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
1.3000000
|
0.9000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
SlatevsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.7000000
|
0.7000000
|
1.3000000
|
0.9000000
|
3
|
5
|
3
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
WoodvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Acrylic
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Walker 2002
|
2002
|
641.0000000
|
142.0000000
|
543.0000000
|
182.0000000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Polymer
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
25x1.2m diameter, 25x1.5m diamter
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
RockvsTire
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer_rubber
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.77
|
-80.14
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Text
|
|
|
Walker 2002
|
2002
|
641.0000000
|
142.0000000
|
522.0000000
|
128.0000000
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Density
|
Fish
|
Fish_Concrete
|
Fish_Rock
|
Fish
|
N
|
|
Fish
|
All
|
|
|
|
25x1.2m diameter, 25x1.5m diamter
|
1
|
Y
|
Reef
|
mixed
|
RockvsConcrete
|
Limestone
|
Rock_limestone
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
12.000000
|
25.77
|
-80.14
|
USA
|
Atlantic
|
Reef
|
sheltered
|
NS
|
Text
|
|
|
Gersun et al. 2016
|
2016
|
3.5800000
|
1.0500000
|
2.5000000
|
0.9700000
|
15
|
15
|
15
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Algae_Clay
|
Algae_Rock
|
Algae
|
Y
|
Coralline_Algae
|
EncrustingCoralline
|
All
|
Corallinales
|
Corallinales
|
|
9.1x9.7
|
0.0094
|
Y
|
Tile
|
upward facing
|
marblevsceramic
|
marble
|
Rock_marble
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Clay_unglazed
|
Clay
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
6.000000
|
-27.524722
|
32.676944
|
2 mile reef, South Africa
|
Indian Ocean
|
Reef
|
subtidal
|
NS
|
Table 4
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
138.0600000
|
20.3820000
|
158.1210000
|
29.2960000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
RockvsPerspex
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
138.0600000
|
20.3820000
|
90.2870000
|
17.8344000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
RockvsSteel
|
Sandstone
|
Rock_sandstone
|
Rock_Metal
|
Rock
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
123.0960000
|
11.4600000
|
158.1210000
|
29.2960000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
WoodvsPerspex
|
Turpentine Tree
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Polymer
|
Wood
|
Perspex
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Ushiama2016
|
2016
|
123.0960000
|
11.4600000
|
90.2870000
|
17.8344000
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Density
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Metal
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
mixed
|
WoodvsSteel
|
Turpentine Tree
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Metal
|
Wood
|
Steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal_steel
|
Metal
|
NA
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
-33.83
|
151.29
|
Australia
|
East
|
Reef
|
exposed
|
Significant
|
Figure 3
|
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
0.7000000
|
0.7000000
|
1.3000000
|
0.7000000
|
3
|
3
|
3
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - West Harlem Piers
|
North Atlantic
|
Riprap
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
Significant
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Vaz-pinto et al 2013
|
2013
|
2.4545500
|
0.4723649
|
0.7272730
|
0.6298360
|
12
|
12
|
12
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Polymer
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Invertebrates (and algae)
|
All
|
|
|
|
7x7cm
|
0.0049
|
Y
|
Tile
|
|
FibreglassvsBassalt
|
Basalt
|
Rock_basalt
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
1m
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
3.000000
|
37.7804
|
25.497
|
Sao Miguel, Azores
|
Mid-Atlantic
|
Marinas_winter deploy_3
|
Sheltered
|
Significant
|
Figure2a/b- Winter deployment
|
Added native and non-native species together
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
2.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Wood
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
woodvsceramic
|
Wood
|
Wood_unclassified
|
Wood_Clay
|
Wood
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Reid et al 2015
|
2015
|
1.0000000
|
0.0000000
|
0.5000000
|
0.5000000
|
2
|
3
|
2
|
Richness
|
Sessile
|
Sessile_Clay
|
Sessile_Rock
|
Sessile
|
N
|
|
Sessile
|
Algae/Invertebrate
|
|
|
|
11x11cm
|
0.0121
|
Y
|
Tile
|
Parallel to shoreline (vertical or slanted)
|
CeramicvsArylic
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Clay
|
Rock
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
Ceramic_unglazed
|
Clay
|
|
subtidal
|
Final
|
2.000000
|
40.6683
|
74.0455
|
USA - Harlem River Park
|
North Atlantic
|
Seawalls
|
Exposed/sheltered
|
HarlemRiverPark
|
Table 5 onwards - tables only
|
Only settlement plates from the full 2 month deployment can be considered. All plated deployed sub tidally. But on different ‘background’ substrates (seawalls vs gabions), this is considered OK, as we’re looking for overall trends in colonisation of materials, and can take background substrate into account if needed. No mobile spp data can be included from this study as the results were from complete settlement structures including multiple materials, all grouped together. Replicates varied across sites and settlement plate material.
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
42.8800000
|
NA
|
26.9800000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
42.8800000
|
NA
|
34.8500000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
42.8800000
|
NA
|
35.1500000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Density
|
Benthic
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
1.9432000
|
NA
|
0.7603000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Concrete
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Concrete
|
Rock
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
Concrete
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
1.9432000
|
NA
|
0.8529000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
Fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer_fibreglass
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|
|
Urh2017
|
2017
|
1.9432000
|
NA
|
1.4423000
|
NA
|
2
|
2
|
2
|
Cover
|
Sessile
|
Invert_Polymer
|
Invert_Rock
|
Invert
|
No
|
|
|
All
|
|
|
|
14x14cm
|
0.0196
|
y
|
Tile
|
downfacing
|
|
Slate
|
Rock_slate
|
Rock_Polymer
|
Rock
|
PVC
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer_mix
|
Polymer
|
NA
|
Floating
|
Final
|
4.602738
|
42.363667
|
71.034167
|
USA
|
East Boston Shipyard and Marina located in Boston, Massachusetts
|
Tiles
|
NA
|
|
Table 3
|
|